Harvard Defends Honorary Degree to UC Berkeley’s Elaine Kim, Withholds Degrees Over Pro-Palestinian Protest, Appoints Shaul Magid
Harvard University has defended its decision to award an honorary degree to Elaine Kim, a professor emerita from UC Berkeley known for her support of boycotts against Israel, during its recent Commencement ceremony. While the university distanced itself from Kim's beliefs, it faced criticism for this decision amid broader controversies involving its stance on pro-Palestinian activism. Harvard has also withheld degrees from students who participated in a pro-Palestinian protest, a move the institution stands by without regret. The university appointed Shaul Magid, a pro-exile Jewish philosopher, as Professor of Modern Jewish Studies in Residence, framing this as part of its efforts to counter antisemitism on campus. Critics, including playwright David Mamet, have condemned Harvard's handling of these issues, accusing the institution of failing to uphold human dignity and refusing to consider apologies or reforms. The controversy has sparked a debate over Harvard's legacy and its approach to free speech and hate speech in the context of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.